Saturday, February 11, 2012

It shouldn't hurt, but it does...

Is there any feeling in the world more hurtful than rejection?

I doubt it. I know as a young boy, I was so afraid of this feeling that I almost ended up a bachelor for life. But I was a boy then and I'm a man now. Rejection should no longer have the same kind of power, right?

Wrong!

I still struggle against rejection all the time now. I'm happily married, have two wonderful children, have a permanent job that I love, friends that support me, a house, cars, all of the people and things that are supposed to bring me self assurance. Yet rejection still makes me want to hide my head in the sand. Rejection still makes me want to cry. And I hate crying....

This week at work, I had a pretty powerful conversation with a group of grade 7 girls. One of these girls I have been working with regularly all year. She struggles to control her emotions and spends a great deal of her life being controlled by them which leads her to all sorts of terrible situations. I'm sure she has felt her share of rejection in her life. During the course of our conversation, she made a comment to the effect of, "You don't teach anyone. Everyone agrees. I can't wait until it hits you, because you don't even know what a bad job you are doing and how much everyone agrees with me."

Being an adult, being a teacher of middle school students (by choice) and being quite frustrated at this point, "I'm sorry you feel that way. It's a good thing my self-esteem doesn't rely on your approval or the approval of other 12 year olds. Trust me, if I was looking to be popular, I wouldn't be teaching middle school." This didn't score me too many points during that conversation, but it did shut  down that particular tangent.

Later, 3 friends of this girl decided to meet with me and the girl in order to broker a peace. They presented their points maturely and really worked to express themselves fairly. They made some good points to both the girl and me and I was most definitely able to take some good out of the conversation and I think the 3 girls felt like they were heard. All and all a good meeting, although there was another mention of my teaching during this conversation. The feeling was that I mark very hard and this was hurting their confidence and lowering their motivation to do well in the class.

Like I said, I listened. Like I said, my self-esteem doesn't rely on the approval of 12 year olds. Like I said rejection still makes me want to cry.

What these girls don't know, is that I have worked very hard to be the best teacher I can be for them. There is no assignment in my class that is considered finished. If a student wants to demonstrate more learning, they are welcome to fix-up, redo or alter the assignment in order show me that they have learned the necessary skills or concepts.

As a consequence, I refuse to lower my standards. Students cannot receive an A without meeting the requirements of an A*. This pedagogy is based on principles that I believe are sound, important and relevant to education. I don't regret the choices I've made in my class. I tried to encourage those girls to come in and improve their grades. I hope they will.

I don't regret the work I've done this year. I'm proud of my changing and evolving pedagogy. I felt a great deal of pride in my students' ability to talk to me about their concerns and the trust they showed me in doing so. However, I did the feel the sting of rejection. It hurt even more for all of the attention I've tried to give to their learning. Is there anything worse than trying your best to care for another and being rejected?

As a child, I always figured that adults wouldn't have to worry about rejection. I now know better. Rejection is only able to hurt someone who cares, and I care about a lot in my life. Fortunately, as an adult, I know how to overcome the feeling of rejection. A huge thanks to wife, who helped me understand the teenage girl's mind, and a colleague who reassured me that my thinking is on the right track and provided some ideas to help me motivate my students to achieve their potential.

This time instead of running from rejection or abandoning my principles to avoid feeling rejected, I faced the feeling, reflected on it, looked to others for support and, slowly, overcame it. It still hurt, but not so much as it used to.

*In rereading my blog post, I thought this sounded pretentious, and that was not my intention. I'll provide an an example in the hopes of clarifying my meaning and removing, at least some, of that feeling of condescension. I am humanities teacher. Clear communication is an expectation of every assessment in my class. When a student communicates an ideas with ambiguity or inaccurate vocabulary, they will not receive top grades. Especially since I'll let a student try it over and over, and guide them through any mental blocks until they are satisfied with the result.

Saturday, February 4, 2012

Starting with the End in Mind

Recently, I completed the 3 day training course on Seven Habits of Highly Effective People by Stephen Covey. It's a pretty intense course. The concepts are so simple, but once you start thinking about trying to make these a habit, the level of introspection and thought really goes through the roof. If you don't know what the Seven Habits are and you really are interested try this link. It's a good start. http://bit.ly/pIR8

To me the Habits make sense. Be Proactive, Think Win-Win, Seek First to Understand and Synergize really are habits that I attempt to use regularly in my life. I guess that's what I appreciate about the program. I didn't learn anything earth shattering; I was already trying to live this way even though I didn't use Covey-speak before the course; what the course did was allow the time and provide me with some new tools to reflect on what I am doing now and how to do it better in the future.

After some serious reflection, the three Habits that believe need the most work in my life are Habits 2,3 & 7. Start with the End in Mind, Put First Things First and Sharpen the Saw. One quick and easy fix I saw as the course progressed is that writing is actually a way for me to sharpen my saw. I then realized that I haven't written much of anything since October. So here I am, again, starting up with the blogging thing. One way of sharpening my saw; small, easy commitments being better than nothing.

Today I really want to focus on Habit 2. The most important idea involved with Starting with the End in Mind is to write a personal mission statement. Thinking about those characteristics and principles that I want to base my life on. What I want people to remember about me on my 80th birthday. I started this during the course, so for this post I am just going to list what I wrote then and add to the list as items come to mind. I don't plan on posting my mission statement.

Here are the principles I find most important today, in no particular order:
-demonstrate unconditional love
-listen and seek to understand those around me
-support others with their important missions
-support my own important missions
-be confident enough to be vulnerable with those around me by sharing and defending what is important to me
-create order and routines in my life that take care of the administrivia so I can focus most of my energy on those things which matter most
-form strong, stable teams in which members support one another and achieve greatness together
-learn as much as I can as often as I can
-pass on what I learn in relevant and inspiring ways
-forgive those who hurt me
-move beyond my mistakes and scars
-have fun, laugh and carry my own weather
-be brave enough to speak my mind, yet considerate enough to listen to others

As I said, there is no ranking of these, only the order they appeared in my head. But as I look on them, they feel right, which is a start. Next I have to write them so they make sense and finally I must live them. I feel like Habit 3, making these principles the most important compass of my life is by far the most difficult of the 7 Habits I've learned about. I'll try to report how well that goes.